MCINDOE PROCEDURE FOR VAGINAL AGENESIS: LONG-TERM OUTCOMES AND EFFECT ON
QUALITY OF LIFE.
Christopher J. Klingele, M.D., John B, Gebhart, M.D., Andrew J. Croak, D.O.,
Connie S, DiMarco, M.D., Raymond A. Lee, M.D. Section of Urogynecology/Pelvic
Reconstructive Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
OBJECTIVES: To assess the long-term outcomes of the McIndoe
procedure for vaginal agenesis and evaluate its effect on quality of life.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The medical records of women with
vaginal agenesis treated with the McIndoe procedure at the Mayo Clinic between
January 1950 and January 2000 were identified through a computer search. Medical
records were abstracted for pertinent information, including initial
postoperative course and long-term follow-up. All patients had an extensive
history, physical exam, and radiographic evaluation when deemed necessary.
Psychological referral was offered. Eligible patients were mailed an in-depth
questionnaire to assess long-term outcomes and quality-of-life issues.
RESULTS: 224 women were identified who underwent the McIndoe
procedure for vaginal agenesis. 72/224 (32% response rate) responded to an
in-depth questionnaire focusing on the number of subsequent surgical procedures,
urinary or anorectal dysfunction, complication of the harvest site/neovagina,
functional use, self-image, body appearance and quality of life issues. Overall
satisfaction and patient understanding of vaginal agenesis was assessed. Charts
were reviewed for surgical findings and immediate postoperative results. The
average age at time of surgery was 21.3 (range 15-49 years). Mean operating time
was 135 minutes (range 90- 187 minutes). Average number of days in the hospital
was 9 days (range 4-14). Percent take of skin graft at time of temporary mold
removal was 85%. Infection rate in the immediate postop period was 3% of
patients (2 graft infections and 4-donor site infections). 13% of patients had
previous attempts at surgical correction. Vaginal infection ! after recovery was
only a frequent problem in 7% of patients. Urinary incontinence was never or
only occasionally a problem in 89% of patients, while 8% had daily urinary
incontinence. 3% of respondents reported weekly loss of stool without control.
Burning at donor site was found in 8.5% of respondents, with 20% experiencing
skin irritation. 86% of patients wore the mold postoperatively with the majority
of patients wearing it for 8-12 months postoperatively. 70% found the mold
manageable while 30% found it a daily nuisance. 31% found the graft site
disfiguring. Further surgery was required in12% of patients. 89% of patients
were sexually active after the procedure with 81% able to achieve orgasm. Two
patients felt their vagina was not functional. Self-image after the procedure
was improved in 55% of women. 78% of women stated the McIndoe procedure improved
their life. 21% of women after undergoing the procedure would have considered
using dilators. Finally, 32% report! ed confusion understanding their diagnosis
at the time of surgery
CONCLUSION: Surgical correction of vaginal agenesis by the
McIndoe procedure provides a satisfactory and functional vagina in the majority
of patients. Complications of surgery are minimal and overall satisfaction with
vaginal function is high. Patient counseling should be thorough to fully
disclose the nature of their vaginal agenesis, and discuss the surgical
procedure and likely outcome with respect to function, body changes and risk of
minor problems.
Key Words: Vaginal Agenesis, McIndoe, and Quality of life